Verifier Report — Idiovol Walkthrough Demo

Date: 2026-05-11 Mode: Standard Status: PASS

Checklist

# Check Status Details
1 Root files (CLAUDE.md, README.md, MEMORY.md, .gitignore) PASS All four present at walkthrough root.
2 Skills — 4 SKILL.md files PASS discover/, strategize/, analyze/, write/ each contain SKILL.md.
3 Agents — 13 .md files PASS 13 agents present: coder, coder-critic, data-engineer, explorer, explorer-critic, librarian, librarian-critic, orchestrator, strategist, strategist-critic, verifier, writer, writer-critic.
4 Rules — 7 .md files PASS agents, content-invariants, content-standards, logging, quality, workflow, working-paper-format.
5 References — 4 .md files PASS coding-standards-r, domain-profile, journal-profiles, personal-style-guide.
6 Data — 5 .rds files PASS comp.funda.rds, crsp.ccmxpf_lnkhist.rds, crsp.dsf.rds, crsp.msenames.rds, ff_factors_daily.rds.
7 Scripts — analysis.R, build_factors.R PASS Both present in scripts/.
8 Output tables — table1..6 + table3b_ff4_alphas PASS All 7 .tex table fragments present (table1_summary, table2_sorts, table3_alphas, table3b_ff4_alphas, table4_fm, table5_subperiods, table6_size).
9 Output figures — fig{1,2}_*.{pdf,png} PASS All 4 figure files present (PDF + PNG for fig1 and fig2).
10 output/slide_bundle.rds PASS 24,375 bytes; generated 2026-05-11 18:23.
11 Paper artifacts — main.tex, references.bib, main.pdf, latexmkrc PASS All present. main.pdf (167,596 bytes) newer than main.tex (18:44:09 vs 18:43:48).
12 quality_reports/ files PASS All required reports present: literature-review(+-critique), data-assessment(+-critique), strategy-memo(+-critique), code-critique, writing-critique, research_journal.
13 assets/screenshot_claude_code.png + assets/README.md PASS Both present in assets/.
14 LaTeX freshness — PDF newer than TeX source PASS PDF stamp 2026-05-11 18:44:09 > TeX stamp 18:43:48 (21 s newer). No compile error in main.blg.
15 INV-9 — biblatex + biber, not natbib/bibtex PASS \usepackage[backend=biber, ... natbib=true]{biblatex} at lines 68–79 of main.tex. No \bibliographystyle / \bibliography{} / standalone natbib package.
16 INV-10 — hyperref second-to-last, cleveref after PASS \usepackage[...]{hyperref} at lines 112–114; \usepackage[nameinlink]{cleveref} at line 117 (immediately after).
17 INV-14 — set.seed() once at top PASS analysis.R line 65, build_factors.R line 21. Exactly one call per script.
18 INV-15 — libraries at top PASS analysis.R libraries at lines 54–62 (before here::i_am() at 64 and any computation). build_factors.R libraries at lines 14–17.
19 INV-16 — no absolute paths; here:: everywhere PASS Both scripts call here::i_am() and here::here() for paths.
20 INV-19 — no setwd, rm(list=ls()), install.packages, attach, detach PASS Zero matches in either script.
21 No TODO / TBD / FIXME in paper/main.tex PASS Grep returned no matches.
22 All \input{../output/tableN_*.tex} resolve PASS 7 inputs in main.tex (lines 485, 630, 690, 738, 781, 813, 900) — every target file exists in output/.
23 Slide deck rendered HTML present PASS _site/teaching/talks/writing-a-paper-in-15min/index.html (64,743 bytes).
24 20 H2 slides in rendered HTML PASS Source index.qmd contains 20 ^## headings; rendered HTML contains 20 slide sections (<h2> count = 20).
25 Slide assets copied to _site/.../claude-code-walkthrough/ PASS output/fig1_idiovol_ls.png, output/fig2_quintile_returns.png, paper/main.pdf, assets/screenshot_claude_code.png all copied through Quarto.

Summary

  • Mode: Standard (Checks 1–4 + content-invariant sweep)
  • Checks passed: 25 / 25
  • Critical invariants (INV-9, INV-10, INV-14, INV-15, INV-16, INV-19): all clean
  • Compilation freshness: main.pdf rebuilt 21 s after the most recent main.tex save; latexmk with XeLaTeX + biber per latexmkrc
  • Cross-references: every \input{} resolves; every figure file referenced from index.qmd exists in the rendered _site/
  • No dangling TODO/TBD in the manuscript
  • Demo subfolder inventory matches the brief exactly (CRSP/Compustat + FF factors data, 7 tables, 2 figures × 2 formats, slide bundle, full .claude/ skill+agent+rule+reference set, all paired critique reports)

Overall: PASS

Back to top